Ordered 20 received 15 peace nice mix and 5 21 Morgan 1 semi slick out of the lot sweet deal

Received all 1920’s Peace dollars. All were toned, but no wear or damage. Will get more.

Got a 1922 Peace dollar in very good condition. Very happy with my purchase.

Two orders 12 total all peace and unless cleaned nowhere near cull awesome Provident

The silver dollars I received were a mix of Morgan and Peace dollars. Contrary to what they advertise, I did receive a Morgan without a “discernible date”. That was disappointing but the other coins I received were better than expected and they were all different dates. I would buy them again, but Provident needs to ensure that these coins do have a date on them as advertised.

Got 10 all Peace but only one is what I would call cull. The rest were VG to Fine. The cull was really just dirty and tarnished. Plus they came in a tube. Good purchase.

I have bought my share of Silver Dollars from Provident. Usually it is a separate choice between Morgans and Peace. Of course I, like everyone else choose Morgans. Nobody is buying Peace Dollars hardly, the rags are full of Peace Dollars. They just don’t sell. This new provident product is thier way of dumping Peace Dollars and telling you they are a mix-not so much a mix. “Maybe” you will get 1 Morgan per 5 or 10 Peace -thats about it.

Provident Response: We are sorry that you did not receive the mix of coins you were hoping for. Please keep in mind that the coins we ship are based on our existing inventory which at any given point in time may or may not contain a mix of types. In our product description, we explain this when we state “Orders of multiple coins may or may not contain a mixture of types, dates, and mint marks.” These coins are being sold as cull silver dollars and carry minimal collector value. Generally, people buying cull silver dollars are purchasing simply as an investment in silver rather than for numismatic purposes. If you are looking for a specific coin to add to your collection, we recommend, in the future, purchasing the specific type of coin you wish to receive rather than leave it up to chance and possible disappointment.

Ordered Provident ‘Cull’ dollars expecting damaged or worn Peace dollars. Couldn’t believe when I opened the box I got ALL XF+ Morgans. I love pleasant surprises!

Received only Peace dollars however much better than “cull” in my opinion. Better luck next time!

Some of the coins are in pretty good condition considering they are almost 100 years old! I ordered 22 of these coins and got all 1921 Morgan dollars. I’m a bit disappointed I didn’t get any Peace dollars. That leaves me without peace. ;)

I ordered 9 of these and all 9 were Peace Dollars…no Morgans…at little disappointed. All in all the quality was good though.

Ordered ten of these and got 7 Peace and 3 Morgans. All in great shape considering they are culls. A couple of the Peace dollars are in way better condition than typical cull coins. One Morgan has a couple grooves cut into the edge but they are very small and minimal.
Ordering ten more right now.

I ordered five of these. I received Three Peace Dollars and Two Morgan’s. One Morgan had a few chunks out of it but still Cull Coins. The rest were in very good condition… I’m very glad I ordered them. Putting five more on my next order. I still rated them as 5 Stars… I’m happy with my order… Thanks Provident!

Low funds this week so made a small order of ASE’s and added 1 of these to qualify for free shipping. Keeping my fingers crossed hoping for a Morgan!!! PROVIDENT ROCKS!!!

I bought 5 of these. Here is how I graded them:
Morgan 1885 O AG-3
Peace 1922 S AG-3
Peace 1923 VF-20
Peace 1924 AU50
Peace 1924 s VG-8

I bought 7 of these and most are in great condition for cull. I was hoping for at least one Morgan but all 7 were Peace Dollars. Overall I’m happy with my purchase

I ordered 10 of these and received all Peace dollars, most in decent shape. Would have liked a Morgan or 2, but for the price still a good deal.

I ordered a few of these the other day. A great price. The mix i receive really doesnt matter but im extremely excited anticipating what I’ll receive. Honestly hoping for the majority to be Morgans! The only thing i know for sure is that PROVIDENT will deliver. Great Company!!!

I took a huge risk and ordered 2 coins in the hopes of getting at least 1 Morgan. I have nothing against the Peace dollar, it’s just that I already have a 1923 Peace dollar that was given to me as a gift by my great uncle. Well…I got my order today and SURPRISE!!, I got 2 Peace dollars: a 1923 with the only major defect being that the “ST” in “TRVST” and the “Y” in “LIBERTY” is not prominently raised possibly due to a mfg defect as the rest of the coin is very well detailed showing little wear and quite shiny, and a 1924-S in average circulated condition with some wear, toning and scratches. Overall not bad as the coins are better than cull as others have stated, but didn’t get a Morgan. I’d probably just order a Morgan directly next time instead of trying this.

Received 2 very nice Peace dollars which I have no problem with, a ’22 S and a ’35 P…the 35 was in great shape, great luster and sharp…I don’t see how they could make this one a cull, but I’m not a coin grader…I will order more in the future! Merry Christmas my fellow collectors, along with the folks at Provident!

Always been pleased with all my coins never go anywhere else.

Bought 2 coins and was prepared to get all Peace Dollars due to the comments but ended up getting a Morgan and a Peace which is what i wanted. The coins are definitely not “culls” and are in great shape. The shipment came real fast. Definitely recommend!

I have never been disappointed in the quality of my purchases from Provident; however, this time I purchased 300 cull Morgan and Peace dollars. Not one Morgan in the lot. Couldn’t you at least throw in one Morgan it make it interesting–and accurate?

These coins are very nice “culls”. I have seen Peace Dollars locally in worn condition for much higher prices. Do not expect any rare stuff, but you will not be disappointed by the quality of these.

I just received anther order of these. Purchased 6 only received 1 Morgan this time a 1921 but great condition. Only one i would say was really cull a 1924 peace and I have paid more for worse at coin shows. There was also 1 1922 which had some type of finish on it but was good condition. And then 3 1923 peace in 3 different conditions, all well better than cull and one in very good condition. Have another 6 on the way soon. Buy them now while silver is so cheap..

Ordered 6 of the Cull Silver Dollars. Received 6 different years ,Morgan “O” mint dollars. All in very good condition. Thank you , Provident.

Ordered 20 and received all “Peace” dollars. I was prepared for this possibility after reading other reviews. None of the coins was particularly ‘worn’ but all were discolored to varying degrees, hence the ‘cull’ designation, I suppose. Agree with others, Provident should list ‘cull’ Morgans & Peace dollars separately. Some might be willing to pay a buck or two more per coin to be assured receiving Morgans. I like ’em both, but all things being equal, I’d prefer to bulk up my stack of Morgans. Been hard (for me anyway) to find Morgan/Peace dollars in decent shape (no holes, bent, or slicks) for under $20 a coin, so great value on that front. Also, my coins came in a nice plastic coin tube (perhaps because I ordered 20, enough to fill a tube) I would definitely order again.

I ordered 10 and received all Morgans. None of them were cull in my opinion. This was a great buy and I will be buying more of these down the line as I have been to this point. Long time Provident customer and always pleased with the service, selection and pricing of their items. Recommend to all customers out there !

I ordered 10 and received 6 Peace and 4 Morgans. Only 1 could be called cull. I love how generous Provident is with their grading.

After I had called provident to request Morgan’s for my order they said they could only ship what was available at the time of ordering. I decided to order anyway after online and ordered 6 coins and to my surprise I received all Morgan dollars. I received an 1890,1896, 1896o, 2 1901, and a 1921. 4 of them were in better condition than listed. I was very happy with these and would purchase again.

PROVIDENT METALS HAS ALWAYS TREATED ME IN DEEP RESPECT, AND YOU CAN TELL BY THE PRODUCTS YOU RECEIVE. THEY ARE ” TOPS ” AND ALWAYS ON TIME.

I ordered 10 and got all Peace dollars, no Morgans, that’s why only 4 stars, however I am VERY pleased with the coins I got. An assortment of years and MINTMARKS and most of the coins are in Very Fine condition or better! Very happy and I will no doubt order more!

I purchase from provident on occasions, and they have never disappointed me with the quality, I received 6 coins: Morgans 1884, 1899, 1888, 1898… Peace: 1922, 1922. all in circulated condition……….

Coins were in much better than cull. Received both Morgans and Peace in an order of 5. All different. Great deal.

I bought two good and extra fine Morgan and peace dollars to compare and after I gave my cull peace dollar a gentle clean with water and a microfiber cloth it was just as nice as the others! I just wish they would have given me a Morgan but it seems everyone has the same problem with only getting peace dollars which doesn’t seem fair or very honest. They should be more up front about the maybe 10% chance you will get a Morgan dollar vs a 90% chance you will get a peace dollar. But otherwise I was happy even though Christmas slowed their shipping down from normal speed which has previously been fast. Nonetheless I highly recommend provident metals over the other guys! Buy with confidence!

All 6 were Morgans pre 1900 from good to very fine with a lot of dark toning. A good value for the price.

I WAS SURPRISED OF THE QUALITY OF THE COINS–NO COMPLAINTS. GOOD COMPANY TO DO BUSINESS WITH

I just purchased 4 of these on Provident Metal’s Cyber Monday sale and I received 4 Morgan Dollars for a great price. Two were in very nice condition and two were in true cull condition. I am very pleased with this order and will be back to buy more. Thanks again Provident Metals for your great products, pricing and service !

I just received 2 excellent Morgans out of 2 ordered. Always order a few and get a mix.

Just received my order of 200, of which every single coin was a Peace dollar (not a single Morgan!).

Paid by check, and it took a full month (28 days) to receive goods.

That said, the quality was excellent, considering they’re supposed to be “culls.” Most were in circulated but very good condition (VG) condition, and the top 10% was XG or AU.

I know I just reviewed these a few days ago, but I just received my first Morgan after ordering several coins one at a time. It was extremely low grade especially when compared to the Peace’s from the same order (as I suspected). I’ll say I was pleasantly surprised to see a Morgan in the bag, but less than surprised to see its quality. Be happy with the average circulated Peace dollars you receive. I got what I wanted/paid for.

I’ve ordered several of these, all once at a time thrown in with a bigger order. They’ve all been Peace dollars, in (my opinion) average circulated condition. So I have no complaints. I would assume any Morgan’s I would have gotten would be in worse (cull) condition. I plan to keep buying more. With free shipping, this is better than you can do buying junk silver on ebay.

Ordered 50 coins. As soon as I ordered I contacted customer service twice hoping to get more Morgans. I wasn’t guaranteed but was promised that there will be a note put on my order ” to get more Morgans”. Received my order today, I was hoping at least 10 out of 50 would be Morgans, but got 1 Morgan and 49 peaces, its good that didn’t order 100 which I wanted to at first place. Condition of the coins better than cull, but the title should say peace dollars not mixed Morgan and Peace dollars. As I can see from reviews majority of people got peace dollars also.

Ordered and received 25. Of the lot, 5 were Morgan and the remaining 20 were Peace. 2 of the Morgan dollars were AU with very slight imperfections. The other 3 were circulated but not unattractive. The Peace dollars were all average circulated. Overall, I was pleased, especially since I was expecting “culls”. I will order this again whenever I get a chance.

Recieved all Peace Dollars in early 20’s. All different and all in very good condition.

One has a brass spot on the back after being attached to something, the other has a dent on each side, and the other one looks perfect and it’s a lower mintage as well.

I am impressed with these dollars. I would order these again.

just recieved 14 and was very pleased

Title said Morgans and Peace Dollars. Only ordered five but thought I would get at least one Morgan. Maybe next time. The Peace Dollars I am pleased with.

Culls for sure ordered four all were Peace two were worn to having no rims and one had some sort of dirt on it the last was an ok coin. No jumping out of the chair for me. Had already ordered 10 more before I saw these based on the prior reviews.
I guess you have to accept culls for what they are.

Ordered 4 coins all were Peace. Two were worn to the point the rim was gone. One was dirty will see how it cleans up.The last was an ok coin.Just wanted these to go with my other 90% silver.Had already ordered 10 more before I saw these based on other reviews.Maybe they came from the bottom of the bag.

ordered 12 and was all Peace dollars. Was hoping for Morgans. I ordered 3 this time so we’ll see how it goes.

I ordered 4 coins to test the waters and I could not be happier! I got one Peace that looks great and 3 Morgans. One Morgan is an 1899 that is pretty worn down, mainly at the edges, but the date is easily visible and the coin actually looks great after its years of use. Got a 21 with really nice toning on it, and an 1890 that is amazing! The 1890 is super shiny, I actually said a few words out loud that I cannot put here because I was so amazed with its quality! I will absolutely be buying more of these coins and cannot wait to see what I get.

I collect coins as well as stack silver. I came into a bit of cash and decided to gamble on 10 cull silver dollars. I’m an amateur when it comes to grading coins but I’d have to say that only two of the coins were truly culls and the rest were good to very good. Two of the coins had also been cleaned at some point as well. I received 8 morgans from 1882 to 1900 and two peace dollars. I had two 1900 morgan Os and the rest were different mints/dates. There was also two dollars which were not exactly rare but not exactly common ether and I put those to the side for my personal collection.

It beats going to consignment shops and local coin shops in my town by far and I’ll probably put in another order in the future.

Re-energized, I decided to try an order of 20 cull SDs, but drew to an inside straight again … only 1 Morgan (which had seen better days) in the shipment. The coins were up to Provident’s high standard, but was hoping for a better MIX.

Last week I thought I’d try another cull SD order (but smaller) and see if I got better mix of Peace and Morgans, and imagine my surprise when they were all Morgans this time! No “smoothies” or holed, good dates, and they were actually in much better shape than I expected. Thank you Provident!

Got ten…9 Morgan’s and 1 Peace….Only one morgan was a 21, the rest pre 21…ALL coins were in better than cull state and three were so nice I jumped up out of my chair…wife thought the house was on fire or something….SCORE. Culls from XXXXX are as ugly as Mrs. Doubtfire….Can’t wait to order more!!

21 Morgan, will order again on the chance the next one is this good. Customer service was also very helpful and quick to respond when there was a minor delay in shipping. Will continue to buy from provident.

I ordered 30 culls, and they were in much better shape than I had expected, i.e., not as worn, toned or damaged as I thought some might be. All had dates and no holes.
I was, however, a little disappointed that they were all Peace Dollars, as I had hoped with an order of that size, I might get one or two cull Morgans. Otherwise, 5 star performance!

i received my coin in the mail , the coin was very good . i ll keep buying . thank you

Just bought 10 of these cull dollars, Got 4 Peace and 6 Morgan, four of the Morgan was worn,put two were very good the Peace were in real nice shape, Better than Cull. I got just what I expected, and I’ll be back Shipping was just three days

So I ordered 20 of these Cull Silver Dollars just to see what I would end up with. Most of the reviews talk about getting mostly Peace Dollars and my order was much the same. I received 14 Peace and 6 Morgans. But what made this order stand out was that about 5 or 6 of the Dollars were FAR ABOVE CULL. There were 14 that arrived in a tube but some were missing. I checked the box only to find the remaining coins individually packaged because of their brilliance. I’m NO coin grader at all but it looked as if maybe these coins had been polished but they were in excellent shape, almost to the point of saying G-XF. I wish I could upload pics to show. Although I wish I’d gotten more Morgans because that’s what I collect, I am very pleased with the order and will be back!!!

I have yet to be disappointed by Provident. My ten coins were in better shape than I expected, by far. All ten were peace dollars, no Morgans, but that’s the deal. They’re culls, dude! I suggested Provident to my brother, who is a pretty conservative guy. He jumped in right away.

I’ve been more of a fine silver buyer, but I couldn’t pass up a free shipping offer on these. Mine arrived in surprisingly good condition. I was expecting something illegible and beat up, but it arrived in a flip with a very solid strike on both sides. I was very impressed. Once again, Provident made a repeat buyer from this guy.

Since being new to buying in coins I opted in buying some of these. Ordered online and sent in payment. I was a little nervous with sending in a cashiers check but with all the other reviews I thought I would take a chance. Also I called a couple times and talked to a couple different sales reps both before ordering and before shipping. Vefified payment received and shipping eta. Saw info was posted online, but still wanted to confirm. Sales was nice and curtious. Overall from order to receiving to the door took just over 2 weeks. I could not see losing the %’s with paying on a cedit card. Extra week I’ll keep the %’s myself. I received 1/2 that where cull and half that where better. I would ever say that 2 compared to good-fine condition. Very happy and hope to do some more in a few weeks. Or sonner if silver stays in the 29’s. :)

I got an 1885 morgan! Kinda beat up, but much much better than I ever expected. I can’t believe I got one that’s so old and in as good of shape as it is. I win.

I have several real nice 1922 Peace culls. Great thing to grab on every order.

I bought this to make use of a free shipping offer, and to my delight I received a 1922 Peace that is far from cull. I would buy this product again.

This was my fourth purchase from Provident. The price, customer service and delivery were excellent. Will continue to purchase here.

Only 7 of the twenty I ordered were what I would consider cull..I will buy again!

Ordered 6 and got all 1922 Peace dollars. You would expect to receive at least 1 Morgan out of six, but they all were better than cull so I cannot complain. 1 Peace was sticky with candy or some other substance. Over all satisfied with purchase will be ordering again soon. Next order I will order Low grade Morgan dollars for about the same price.

Most of the coins I have received in multiple orders have been what I’d consider Good or better condition. I think I’ll order more today

Just bought 12 of these cull dollars, Got 11 Peace and 1 Morgan, The Morgan was worn, the Peace were in real nice shape, Better than Cull. I got just what I expected, and I’ll be back

I purchased 3 gold coins, 100 maple leafs and they were as advertised. I also purchased 3 cull silver dollars, 2 were good and 1 was pretty well worn. All were Peace Dollars, would have liked at least 1 Morgan. Over all another good experience with Provident.

I bought 10 coins and I was happy with the coins I received. It’s still better than trying to buy something like this on Ebay. The condition of the coin were good. I will buy from again. You can’t beat the price for the quality of coin…

you get what you pay for. it took a little longer to be shipped then i thought. but once it was shiped it got here really fast. in all pretty happy. after i clean them i payed buy credit card next time owl pay buy check to get the discount.

I was quite surprised in the condition of the one hundred that I ordered. The condition was much better than I was expecting. A very few were worn quite a bit but even those the dates and everything else was readable. Also out of 100 I got twenty-five different dates.

Was left 18 by my late grandfather. Needed two more,to fill a tube, got decent 1880’s examples. If you’re getting cull grade, older is certainly better.

Bought a $100 bag to try out..got better than I expected as only about 20% looked really ‘cull’, so after some minor cleaning I put the whole bunch away in tubes for an inflation hedge. IMHO a great way to invest in ‘acceptable/usable’, US silver.

Bought one coin to test out product. I received an 1879 Morgan. You get what you expect. I will be purchasing these again.